A Little WisdomTalmud stories for everyday life
← All stories

066 · 4 panels

Your Reason Before Mine

Before arguing against another proposal, he tried putting its reason into his own words.

Inspired by a source · Creative adaptationNo sign-up · All stories free
Read at your own pace.
They differed even on how to arrange their walking photos in an album.
Jin

I like date order… Why group them by place?

They differed even on how to arrange their walking photos in an album.

Instead of a rebuttal, he first checked what mattered to Ara.
Jin

Let me explain your idea first. You want to see how the same place changes, right?

Instead of a rebuttal, he first checked what mattered to Ara.

Ara also restated Jin's proposal together with its reason.
Ara

Yes. And your date order would keep the days we shared connected.

Ara also restated Jin's proposal together with its reason.

They made the first spread that way. The reasons behind both proposals remained.
Jin

Then shall we group them by place, with date order inside each group?

They made the first spread that way. The reasons behind both proposals remained.

A thought from the Talmud

When learning differing views, present the other side faithfully before your own.

The source idea in our own words · Not a direct quotation

Eruvin 13b:10–12 · Read the source ↗

A lesson for today

Before evaluating a different proposal, try explaining what matters to the other person and ask whether you understood correctly. Then compare the reasons for each option and choose what suits this situation. You do not have to accept every view or always reach a compromise.

A modern interpretation for this story

A question to take with you

Before explaining my proposal, can I accurately describe the reason that matters to the other person?

Please include the source link when sharing.

If it stayed with you, support us with a follow.

Visit one of Park Seoyeon's channels. If you enjoy a post, a like or a comment is welcome too.

Park Seoyeon is an AI-created fictional character.
Visiting, signing up and following are optional. They are never required to read.

About the source and this adaptation

Eruvin 13b:10–12 discusses a religious-law dispute between the schools of Hillel and Shammai. It describes how Hillel's school also taught the other school's views and presented them before its own. The passage includes a heavenly voice and a religious-law decision; it does not declare that every opinion is always right or can be combined. This AI-assisted modern fiction draws on faithfully presenting another view. Jin, Ara, the photo album, the sorting proposals, their restatements and the ending are invented. The original's religious exaltation or success is not presented as a modern rule guaranteeing rewards.

Read the source ↗

AI-generated artwork · Creative adaptation

For your next little pause

A Card with Two Birthday Wishes →