A Little WisdomTalmud stories for everyday life
← All stories

124 · 8 panels

Can I Move the Hoop?

Get the block inside the hoop without moving the block. Ara read the riddle again.

Inspired by a source · Creative adaptationNo sign-up · All stories free
Read at your own pace.
The green hoop and blue block were apart.
Story

At their game meetup, Jin set a hoop and a block on the table.

The green hoop and blue block were apart.

Jin read the riddle he had written on a cream card.
Jin

How can you put the blue block inside the hoop without moving the block?

Jin read the riddle he had written on a cream card.

Ara reached toward the block, then stopped.
Ara

I feel like I'd have to move the block to get it inside…

Ara reached toward the block, then stopped.

The card only said the blue block had to stay put.
Story

Ara read the riddle again and looked over at the hoop.

The card only said the blue block had to stay put.

Jin checked the card and said there was no rule about where the hoop had to stay.
Ara

Then can I move the hoop?

Jin checked the card and said there was no rule about where the hoop had to stay.

Ara lifted the hoop and set it down around the block.
Ara

Then I'll bring the hoop to the block.

Ara lifted the hoop and set it down around the block.

They looked down at the new arrangement.
Jin

The block hasn't moved, and now it's inside the hoop!

They looked down at the new arrangement.

Ara turned the card over and picked up a pencil.
Ara

My turn to make a riddle.

Ara turned the card over and picked up a pencil.

A thought from the Talmud

When the sages asked how to preserve salt, Rabbi Yehoshua asked whether salt spoils in the first place.

The source idea in our own words · Not a direct quotation

Bekhorot 8b:14–15 · Read the source ↗

A lesson for today

Ara was only thinking about how to move the blue block until she noticed the riddle said nothing about where the hoop had to stay. She put the hoop around the block and solved the puzzle while keeping to the original rule. When a problem seems stuck, we can separate the conditions we've been given from the assumptions we've added.

A modern interpretation for this story

A question to take with you

When a problem won't budge, what might I be assuming is a rule even though nobody set it?

Please include the source link when sharing.

If it stayed with you, support us with a follow.

Visit one of Park Seoyeon's channels. If you enjoy a post, a like or a comment is welcome too.

Park Seoyeon is an AI-created fictional character.
Visiting, signing up and following are optional. They are never required to read.

About the source and this adaptation

In Bekhorot 8b:14, the sages of Athens ask for a tale of nonsense. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Hananya tells them that a mule gave birth. In segment 15, they ask how to preserve salt if it spoils. He answers that they can use a mule's placenta. When they question whether such a thing exists, he asks whether salt spoils. The wisdom line paraphrases this last reply. Jin, Ara, the wooden block and hoop, the rules of the game and the dialogue are AI-assisted modern fiction inspired by the exchange.

Read the source ↗

AI-generated artwork · Creative adaptation

For your next little pause

Starting Again with One Scarf →